Is Scripture Reliable? 4 Common Objections and How To Answer.

There is overwhelming evidence that supports the Bible being exactly what it says it is. Infallible, without error, and useful for building up in righteousness.
February 7, 2024

Scripture claims it is God’s reliable and infallible Word in several places throughout the Bible. Skeptics continue to question the reliability of Scripture. There is overwhelming evidence that supports the Bible being exactly what it says it is. Infallible, without error, and useful for building up in righteousness.

There are four common objections that skeptics make to the reliability of Scripture. Here is a quick guide to those objections and a response to them. 

OBJECTION 1: Oral Tradition is unreliable

Answer: Oral tradition is reliable for three specific reasons.
1. It was held in the highest regard.
2. Jewish children are taught to remember oral material accurately so that it can be handed down.
3. Handed down collectively to the entire community, which meant that it would be reliable because the entire community depended on it.

OBJECTION 2: Written by Men

Answer: Scripture is clear that writers were inspired by God (2 Peter 1:21; 1 Corinth 2:13)

OBJECTION 3: Writers were biased (2 Peter 1:16; 1 John 1:1)

Answer: Historically, some of the most reliable historical reports of events were from those we may consider biased. For instance, reports of the Nazi Holocaust were from Jews, yet we don’t discount them as unreliable. 

OBJECTION 4: Too much time had passed 

Answer: The time between the original and manuscript copying is extremely short. Especially, compared to other documents we hold as accurate. 

Generally, the shorter the time between the original writing and the manuscript, the more reliable a text is considered to be. Ancient classics have an average gap of over 1,000 years. A 700-year gap is considered good among works of antiquity. The chart below shows that New Testament manuscripts are overwhelmingly more accurate and have closer dates than other works.

Author Date Written Earliest Copy Number of Copies Accuracy of Copies
Caesar 1st Century B.C. A.D. 900 10 ___________
Tacitus A.D. 100 A.D. 1100 20 ___________
Thucydides 5th Century B.C. A.D. 900 8 ___________
Herodotus 5th Century B.C. A.D. 900 8 ___________
Homer 9th Century B.C. __________ 643 95%
New Testament 1 Century A.D. 2nd Century A.D. 5,000+ 99+%